0077 Oh Death

0077 Oh Death
(audio player below article)

Oh Death, Oh Death
Won’t you spare me over till another year

But what is this that I can’t see
these ice cold hands take ahold of me
When God is gone and the Devil takes hold
who’ll have mercy upon my soul

Oh Death, Oh Death
No wealth no ruin no silver no gold
nothing satisfies me but your soul
Well I am Death none can excel
I’ll open the door to heaven or hell

Whoa Death, someone would pray
could you wait to call me another day
The children prayed the preacher preached
time and mercy are out of your reach

I’ll fix your feet till you can’t walk
I’ll lock your jaw till you can’t talk
I’ll close your eyes so you can’t see
This very air come and go with me

I am Death come to take your soul
I’ll leave your and leave it cold
I’ll draw your flesh up off your frame
Both dirt and worm will have their claim

Oh Death, Oh Death
My name is Death and the end is here
Your time is come, too late for fear

Oh Death
by Ben Stone

This is a topic I’ve avoided writing about since I completely changed my position in 2007. As a matter of fact, in the past I have only shared my opinion on this topic when directly asked by people whom I care about and respect. I could cut this article short by simply saying that I’m talking about capital punishment, but that’s only one aspect of this topic. What I’m really talking about is death itself and who has the right to decide on death.
It would be easy for me to say that when a person kills another person who is not an immediate threat to someone, it’s murder and it’s wrong. But I don’t believe that statement. This is the position of a lot of people in the liberty movement, but I have problems with it. Let me give some examples and work through some scenarios and we’ll see if I can present my opinion in a way that’s consistent with the Zero Aggression Principle, libertarian Property Rights, and the natural laws that are unique to our species.

The current system of “justice” in the United States of America is so twisted and out of balance that it only occasionally stumbles into a just conviction, however even when it does it lacks the capacity to understand or execute actual justice.

An example of “Justice” in the US.
Bill breaks into Jim’s house and in the course of robbing him Bill kills Jim. The police arrive to find Bill holding the murder weapon and as Jim dies, his last words to the police are, “Bill did this.” There is no question of guilt, however Bill refuses to accept a plea bargain and the case goes to trial. Jim’s widow and children await justice. A State attorney is assigned to Bill for his defense, and the trial begins. The prosecuting attorney presents his case including the testimony of the first responding cop who clearly recalls Jim’s last words. The defense attorney does his best with what he has to work with but finally the case goes to the jury to decide. They take a few minutes to review the case and find Bill guilty of murder and they suggest the death penalty. The judge gives Bill one last chance to come clean but Bill refuses to speak. The judge, seeing no other option, sentences Bill to death by lethal injection.
Who, hearing the above details, could say the State has no right to execute Bill?
I say the State has no right to execute Bill.
Actually I say the State is incapable of executing Bill. The State is not a person. Therefore the State was not harmed nor threatened by Bill so the State has no case against Bill. Additionally, the State has no physical body therefore it must hire an individual who is completely uninvolved with the case to do the actual killing of Bill. When this hired killer injects the lethal dose into Bill’s veins, he is as guilty of murder as was Bill. Actually his crime is worse since Bill is strapped to a table and can’t fight back. At least Jim was free to defend himself!
In addition to the above objection, consider that the testifying cop, the prosecuting attorney, the defense attorney, and the judge are all employed by the State, presenting a conflict of interest. And each of them makes their living by robbing the very people they claim to serve. As a matter of fact, if Jim had failed to pay his taxes and had chosen to defend his home against the theft of the State, there’s a good likelihood that same judge would send out the order for that same cop to enter Jim’s home and kill him if he resisted being abducted. So then how can the State judge Bill when the State regularly does the same thing Bill did?
Another thought to consider is the reality that Bill, once convicted and placed on “death row”, will sit there in prison year after year while the case is appealed over and over until perhaps 20 years or more go by. All the while the State will tax, not only Jim’s widow and children, but also uninvolved people around the country to support Bill and provide him with security, health care, and everything he needs to live comfortably until his eventual execution. And again, if some uninterested person objects to their taxes going to house, feed, care for, and protect scum like Bill year after year, and they attempt to protect their own property by resisting the theft of the State, the State will break into their house and kill them without any more hesitation or remorse than Bill expressed for his actions.
As for the surviving victims of Bill’s crime, justice cannot be obtained by the State’s killing of Bill. Justice can only be obtained when the vengeance of the victims is satisfied and they are repaid for their loss. The State provides no process for either. Also no one but the victims can determine what that vengeance should be and what it takes to repay their loss. Perhaps Jim’s widow sees no value in Bill’s death but needs a man to do the work Jim would have done if he were not killed. Or maybe Jim’s widow is of a religious nature so that she can forgive Bill. Or perhaps Jim’s children go to bed night after night filled with the terror that their father’s murderer is alive and well and could escape or be released at any time. Any honest person could hardly consider this situation an example of justice.
Look at it this way; what if you owned a very special picture of your grandmother that you had cherished for years. Then one night lightning struck a tree outside and caught the house on fire. You just escaped with your life and the whole house including the picture, was lost. If your insurance agent handed you a check for what they determined the value of the loss to be, could it ever take the place of your grandmother’s picture? What if it wasn’t her picture? What if you lost your grandmother in that fire? Would anything the insurance agent could do repay your loss? Of course not. There is no way to measure the loss of the picture and there is certainly no way to measure the loss of your dear loved one.
The same is the case with Jim’s widow and children. Only they can know the depth of their loss and only they can know what justice looks like. And if they feel the need for vengeance, only they can rightfully determine the level of vengeance. Make no mistake; I will not try to twist human nature into some false moral code where vengeance is frowned upon as backward or uncivilized. That is as much a lie of the State as the idea that the State can supply justice! (see The Morality of Revenge) If Jim’s widow wants Bill to die for his transgression she is morally justified in killing him in any manner she chooses, or if she chooses she is justified having a representative kill him, assuming her champion is doing so voluntarily. When Bill took the life of Jim, his life became the property of Jim’s heirs. Not as a slave, but as a payment for the life he took from them. This is the traditional position of most cultures where there was no State distortion of justice. It is the position most natural to our species. And if Jim’s widow takes mercy on Bill it is her right to do so and no representative of the State has the right to supersede her will.

Considering all of the above, the State is incapable of determining or handing out justice. It was neither threatened nor harmed by the actions of the murderer. And the State is openly guilty of the same crime the murderer committed, but many times over. Therefore the State has no right to kill anyone for a crime that took place between private individuals. And since the State is the single largest, most powerful criminal entity in existence, constantly committing aggressive acts of theft, violence, and murder, any act directed at the State is an act of self defense and is justified, however foolish it may be to fight the State. Therefore the State is not morally justified in killing even if the accused is committing an act directly against the State. And since the State lacks justification to kill, any person who kills on behalf of the State is guilty of murder.

Ah, but here may be a catch! The reader may be saying, “What about war? Isn’t war simply killing on behalf of the State? Surly you wouldn’t argue that killing during war is the same as killing at other times!”
I would argue that the vast majority of killing in times of war is simply murder, morally glazed over with the honey of State propaganda. The perpetrator may be brainwashed and therefore delusional as to the justifications of their actions, and this should be considered when judging them, but murder it remains. The exception would be when people are protecting themselves and their property from an invading or encroaching State. An example of this happened in November 1791 when US troops led by Arthur St. Clair, set out from modern day Cincinnati Ohio with the intent of destroying the city of Kekionga of the Miamis. The natives responded with an overwhelming defensive action that resulted in the worst defeat in the history of the US Army. Another example of a morally justified defensive act of war happened on King’s Mountain in North Carolina when British forces under Patrick Ferguson attempted to cut through Appalachia, looting as they went. State history books lie and say Ferguson was attacked by “Colonial Militia” when in fact the Appalachians that decimated Ferguson’s army were simply stateless peaceful people living their lives without taking a side in the war until they were aggressed upon.
Defensive action, whether by individuals or a group as in war, committed while protecting life, liberty, and property are entirely justified and morally acceptable and do not breach the Zero Aggression Principle. Additionally an act of vengeance up to but not exceeding damages done by an act of aggression does not violate the Zero Aggression Principle and is entirely consistent with natural law.

If everything I have said up to this point fails to convince you that capital punishment committed by a State is morally unjust, consider the practical argument. Can the entity that operates such institutional failures as the US Postal Service, the US Border Patrol, the Internal Revenue Service, The BATF, Housing and Urban Development, The US Department of Transportation, and oversees the Federal Reserve, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac, be trusted with life or death when your son is on trial for a crime you believe he didn’t commit?

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and Sin, Bad Quaker and War., Bad Quaker Theology, Free Society, History, Property, Voluntaryism and Competitive Government, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0077 Oh Death

0076 Shake That Tree To Its Roots

0076 Shake That Tree To Its Roots

Shake That Tree To Its Roots
by Ben Stone

Alright!
Enough picking at the low hanging fruit! It’s time to give this tree a good shaking and see what breaks free and what clings to the branches for security.

I don’t know if it’s noticeable or not, but there’s an underlying theme or perhaps an underpinning storyline to my writings. Take the following list of articles available at Bad Quaker Dot Com and notice the brief summary I have attached here:

I have used the Bible and theology and I have used scientific theory to demonstrate my belief in a divided humanity. However Frank Chodorov perhaps made this distinction clearest when he said:
“On the other hand, give a course in classical economics, or teach a group the meaning of natural rights, and some, though they have absorbed all the words of freedom, will come away entirely unconvinced. Some emotional blocking prevents the ideas from taking root. And this is also true of all the collectivistic professors; they read all the books which the individualist holds most dear, but the reading leaves them cold to the ideas; they are collectivist because nature inclined them toward collectivism.”
And again Chodorov pointed out;
“…neither education, background, nor income can explain either the socialist or the libertarian. Whenever you try any of these criteria you are faced with cases that refute your premise; you find that both types come from penthouses and slums, that they include Ph.D.’s and illiterates. You are driven to the conclusion that if there is a causative principle it must be found somewhere in the makeup of the person rather than in environmental influences. ”
Or to put it more simply, Chodorov said, “That is to say, the libertarian teaches not to “make” libertarians, but to find them.”
So an overview of my theory would begin by explaining that something happened, some event took place that caused a divide in humanity. Those tending toward socialism and the law of Man are on one side of this divide and those tending toward individual liberty and natural law are on the other side. One of these two groups will survive the ravages of time while one will not. And it should be noted that I view the State as a developing and maturing entity both serving and feeding upon all who will tolerate it. The State is the creation of the socialists but it will more than happily feed on the libertarians if, in their slothfulness, they choose to host it. Additionally, the State is inherently unstable economically and entirely void of morals.
So then building on this foundation, I believe the course of the State is to grow and absorb all lesser manifestations of itself until it exhausts all available space and food, like some deadly mold infecting everything it encounters. ( The State and Mold) As it does this, the State will become more and more oppressive and its appetite will grow unquenchable until in desperation it will turn on its most faithful supporters and devour them. To say it plainly, the State will never stop until a one-world government dominates all aspects of civil society and controls all known sources of productivity. The emphasis here is on “civil” society and “known” sources of productivity. You see, the State has never been able to control sub-cultures of society nor has it ever been able to successfully combat black markets. And so we see the weakness of this Great Beast and with it we see the weapon that will strike the deathblow.
Hidden productivity and black markets in every conceivable commodity will be developed. Networks of private communication and codes of speak will be worked out. Messages in images, clear to those in-the-know, while strange and hidden to the masses, like gang tags of liberty on the overpasses of the State, will guide the liberty minded to select locations and safe houses as they avoid the eyes of the herd. And make no mistake on this point; libertarians will never be the majority as long as the State lives. So the masses will not only be the tools of the State but at some point they will become openly hostile to us, as the State eventually singles us out as the cause of all its failures. Shortages and oppression are the hallmarks of socialism and the population purges of Hitler, Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot will pale in comparison to the future this world faces when the Beast comes into its maturity.
We exist today in a brief window of relative freedom that is quickly closing. How we in this generation and the next, prepare and take advantage of this pause before the battle, will determine the duration of the battle and the depth of suffering our side endures.

At this point of the discussion it becomes necessary for me to do something I have never done before on the pages of Bad Quaker Dot Com and something I have rarely done at all in the last thirty years. I must attack a religious doctrine. I don’t take this step lightly nor do I take any pleasure in the task. It’s generally my policy to allow people to believe anything they feel comfortable believing so long as they respect my beliefs in return. But on the topic of the so-called “rapture” I must speak out. It’s my contention that the doctrine of the rapture was introduced into Christianity by some of the vilest creatures ever to call themselves “Christian” for the express purpose of weakening those who would naturally be sturdy opponents of the State. The idea that Christians need not make preparations for the coming hardships because at the last moment they will be whisked away to safety is a sick retched joke conceived by none other than that enemy of liberty Cotton Mather, and later picked up by hucksters passing out sugar coated dreams in return for full collection plates.

Murray Rothbard said this about Cotton Mather in volume 2 of his masterpiece Conceived In Liberty:

The Reverend Cotton Mather, always an eloquent and leading spokesman for despotism, warned the slaves and servants in a sermon that “there is a Fondness for Freedom in many of you.” Mather advised the slaves that they were living better materially than they would be under freedom; furthermore, slavery had been appointed for them by God. Singing—for others—the siren song of supposedly contented and blissful security, Mather purred: “Your servitude is gentle . . . you are treated, with more than mere humanity, and fed and clothed and lodged as well as you can wish for, and you have no cares upon you, but only to come when you are called, and to do what you are bidden.” All the subjects must do, in short, was to surrender their naturalborn gift of freedom and independence, to subject themselves completely to the whims and commands of others, who could then be blindly trusted to “take care” of them permanently.

During the 1980’s the rapture doctrine was enjoying almost universal praise by the televangelist crowd. At that time I knew Christians who ran up massive debt because they were convinced they were about to be taken away. They would actually take out loans and give the money to evangelists under the delusion that they would never have to repay it since they would be flying off into the clouds at any moment. A quick Google search into the history of the rapture will reveal it as a relatively new scam, but perhaps a stronger case can be made against this doctrine by simply asking what fruit it produces. Does it produce a Christian who can endure hard times and stand as a testimony to truth and responsibility or one who expects to escape the consequences of his actions?

Where, then, does this leave you and I, a decade into this twelfth millennial since the birth of the State?

If we are wise, we’re making preparations for the dark days ahead. We’re seeking ways to separate ourselves from dependence on the State and its puppet corporations. We’re learning the skills of our forefathers and seeking ways to feed our families and ourselves when the Just-In-Time inventories of the grocery chain stores fail. We’re building networks of like-minded individuals and developing the backbone of future underground railroads to carry to freedom those the State attempts to devour.

This completes the life cycle of the State. Its conception was in the fall of humanity when we chose Man’s law over the natural laws of our species. When the State was born in the fragrant valley of the Jordan River, we failed to smother it in its crib, as we should have. As it grew and tested empire after empire, we tolerated it until it suddenly went out of control and, for the first time, threatened global dominance during the last century. Now that global dominance is immanent and we know that fighting it using its violent weapons will only strengthen it. We can only defeat it by ignoring it, by defunding it, by engaging in free trade, and by peaceful voluntary association. As we find paths around the State and its puppets, we render it impotent and inconsequential. And as it enters its final death throes and begins thrashing about destroying everything within reach including its supporters, we must simply move out of its reach and let it die.

As I’ve said before, if one full generation passes State-free, we will have won and we will once again enjoy the bounties of liberty. But for now, take a look at yourself and your life and ask yourself if you are ready for this tree to shake right down to its roots.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., Bad Quaker Theology, Economics, Free Society, Garden, History, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0076 Shake That Tree To Its Roots

0075 pc23 Racism and Bigotry

Episode 23 Bad Quaker Podcast

Featured in this episode:

  • A request. Help a friend of liberty. Buy a book from the Mises Institute.
  • Racism and bigotry in the liberty movement.

0075 pc23 Racism and Bigotry

Posted in All Podcasts, Free Society, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on 0075 pc23 Racism and Bigotry

0074 PC22 Appalachia and Appalachian Gypsies

Episode 22 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

Original Intro/Exit music by Grenades?!

0074 PC22 Appalachia and Appalachian Gypsies

Posted in All Podcasts, Free Society, History, The Campfire, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0074 PC22 Appalachia and Appalachian Gypsies

Water line fail and a flooded kitchen

Water line fail and a flooded kitchen.

Sorry folks, the last few weeks have handed us one setback after another.

While we mop up and replace what needs to be replaced, here is one of our most popular articles from earlier this year.

Why Must The State Forbid The Duel

The Duel

Before progressing, let us establish exactly what is and is not meant by the word “duel” for the purpose of this article. A duel is not a drunken fistfight. Nor is it to be confused with a trial by combat, although that would make a delightful subject to explore. As well, a duel, for our purposes here, is not the military clash of champions as in David/Goliath or Achilles/Hector.

We are referring here to the settling of a private dispute between two individuals. Private, meaning that for whatever reason, this dispute is taken to a neutral area and only viewed by individuals selected by the combatants as representatives or “seconds”, attending the needs of and representing the combatants, and/or by those selected as witnesses. This form of duel comes to us in Western Culture from the ancient tradition expressed in the Scandinavian word holmgang, however it was by no means unique to northern Europe. The duel, then, being private combat executed by adults under prearranged circumstances and following agreed terms, for the purpose of permanently settling a private dispute.

Click Here To Read More
or Why Must The State Forbid The Duel right click and save for the MP3 version

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Water line fail and a flooded kitchen

0073 pc21 The Purpose Of Bad Quaker Dot Com

Episode 21 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben Stone

Featured in this episode:

  • An introduction to the web site
  • Who are the old ugly dudes pictured across the top of Bad Quaker Dot Com
  • The purpose of Bad Quaker Dot Com
  • The archives of Bad Quaker Dot Com
  • The Zero Aggression Principle and how to change the world
  • Creation, evolution, hopeful monsters, and punctuated equilibrium
  • The paths part, stateless individuals and those dependent on the State

0073 pc21 The Purpose Of Bad Quaker Dot Com

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Bad Quaker Theology, Economics, Free Society, History, The Campfire, Voluntaryism and Competitive Government, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0073 pc21 The Purpose Of Bad Quaker Dot Com

Effects of Fascism and Racism in Africa

Please Note: The Staff of Bad Quaker Dot Com are still in disarray as we assist the KI Vick household in moving to their new place. But for your reading pleasure we present this brief article from Ki.

Effects of Fascism and Racism in Africa

An argument against anarchy that I am presented with nearly as often as the “roads” argument is the case of sub-Saharan Africa. There, we are told, people are starving, disease runs rampant, and only through State-sponsored intervention will these people be saved. Indeed, if you suggest that the governments of the world not interfere with Africa, you are looked at as some kind of heartless, soulless monster. Since most people think of anarchists as soulless atheists bent on destroying society anyway, this myth fits right in. And yet, even as governments all over the “civilized” world give millions of dollars in aid to Africa, the situation seems to be getting more and more dire. How can this be? I make the rather bold claim that government aid is in fact what is causing starvation in Africa, and the effects of fascism and racism are vividly displayed in effects of “do-gooder” politics that runs rampant through that continent.

Where do we begin? The easy place to point out government interference is in the politics of that continent itself. Over many decades, outside governments have meddled in ancient rulers and tribal lands. However, I am not going to get into that today, as it has been written of extensively, and I feel that is low-hanging fruit. I am going to talk about the politics of charity in Africa.

As Westerners, as a “civilized” culture, we look down on indigenous practices such as hunting and gathering. We swoop down, full of pomp and self-righteousness, to “save the heathens” from their “poor” diets of bugs, roots, and meat. A civilized society, you see, eats grains. So we plant these unsustainable crops, and we teach the filthy heathens to stop eating bugs, and begin relying on grains.

“At the conference, Dunkel talked about her frustration working in West Africa, where for decades European and American entomologists, through programs like U.S.A.I.D. and British Locust Control, have killed grasshoppers and locusts, which are complete proteins, in order to preserve the incomplete proteins in millet, wheat, barley, sorghum, and maize. Her field work in Mali focusses on the role of grasshoppers in the diets of children, who, for cultural reasons, do not eat chicken or eggs. Grasshoppers contain essential amino acids and serve as a crucial buffer against kwashiorkor, a protein deficiency that impedes physical and neurological development. In the village where Dunkel works, kwashiorkor is on the rise; in recent years, nearby fields have been planted with cotton, and pesticide use has intensified. Mothers now warn their children not to collect the grasshoppers, which they rightly fear may be contaminated.”

Here we have a prime example of racism. And yet, digging further, we have a prime example of fascism as well. You see, grasshoppers are sustainable, which is to say, they don’t require the consumer to purchase them from a large, State backed corporation. They also don’t require the use of harsh pesticides, herbicides, or fungicides, all of which are produced, subsidized and pushed by various State backed corporations.

So we have a situation where, left to their traditional ways, a society is self sufficient, independent, and healthy. Clearly we can’t have that! So in comes government aid, backed by political pressure from seed corporations dying to get their hands on such a prime market. Lo and behold, the switch to an agrarian culture leads to sickness, starvation, and death. Well, clearly these cultures can’t manage themselves! Look at them, they’re starving! Let’s send in MORE government aid, backed by fascist corporations that make massive amounts of money by supplying these grains to the “charities.” So, in comes more aid, which causes more harm, which causes more aid… a never-ending cycle of State-sponsored degradation.

And could a free-market do better? We are asked that so often. The question of “but at least they’re doing something! Imagine if there were no governments at all!” Yes, imagine that. I’ll give the standard anarchist answer, “A free market couldn’t possibly make things worse than the State does.”

Ki Vick Ki
2011

Quote from https://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/08/15/110815fa_fact_goodyear

Posted in Brief Articles and Short Notes, Economics, Free Society, Garden, Health, History, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Effects of Fascism and Racism in Africa

No Updates Until September 5th 2011

Sorry folks, the whole Bad Quaker Dot Com Team will be helping Ki and her household move to their new place.

Assuming all goes well, Bad Quaker Dot Com will return with articles and podcasts on Monday September 5th, 2011.

We thank you for your understanding in this matter.

For your reading pleasure here is a link to a Bad Quaker Dot Com classic page from the past; From the archive.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on No Updates Until September 5th 2011

0072 PC20 Anonymous Tax Slavery and Appalachia

Episode 20 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

  • Moving days, Thursday and Friday so no articles
  • Hacker group Anonymous and the strike against Wall Street
  • The Zero Aggression Principle, property rights, and Anonymous
  • Is a denial of service attack a moral act?
  • Ben reads a liberal thread from FaceBook and the “I Like Turtles” kid
  • James C. Scott and court languages
  • Pre-Norman Briton and the lack of the State
  • Appalachian history, culture, and some theory

Original Intro/Exit music by Grenades?!

0072 PC20 Anonymous Tax Slavery and Appalachia

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Free Society, History, Property, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0072 PC20 Anonymous Tax Slavery and Appalachia

0071 The Flaw of Corporatism is the Flaw of Statism

0071 The Flaw of Corporatism is the Flaw of Statism MP3
(audio player below article)

The Flaw of Corporatism is the Flaw of Statism
by Ben Stone

The State is easy to pick on. It stomps around hurting and killing people, robbing at will, while spreading the most vile and unfounded lies imaginable. Any good person who has a true encounter with the raw evil of the State can quickly see its retched and hideous nature and will be repulsed by it. Even when the State hides behind the guise of “limited government” every now and then we see the talons and the fangs waiting to emerge at the first opportunity. But the puppets of the State, governments included, are more difficult to discredit because they tend to appear useful or even necessary. This is the case for each puppet of the State, be it governments, the media, the military, the banks, or the most powerful of them all, the corporations. At first glance, corporations seem to be the source of many good things. They engage in manufacturing and trade, they provide jobs and steady incomes, they develop products that improve the lives of millions. So how can anyone equate corporations with the evils of the State?

The obvious answer to that question is that without the aggression of the State there would be no corporations. The corporations exist due to the fist of the State and the force it employs on the market. If I can prove this statement it should be intuitive that anything that exists through the use of aggressive force is unethical and cannot produce a net-good in society. That is not to say that evil cannot do good on a limited scale or in limited circumstances, just that the net production of evil will always be more evil than any good that may occur. So for example, a highwayman may rob the passengers of a coach and then spend his ill gotten gain at the local pub. If you ask the bartender, who has no idea where the highwayman got his money, he may think this customer is a great guy. If you only look through the bartender’s eyes then you only see that the bartender can now better afford to educate his children. If you only look through the barmaid’s eyes, you only see the extra tips that help put food on her table. If you limit your vision to one side of the equation then you could assume the highwayman is a force for good. Corporations spend billions of dollars to keep us all looking through the bartender’s eyes while they use the force of the State to rob the market of its wealth and productivity. But the real point that must be seen, as I attempt to prove my allegations, is that corporations are a product of the State and not a product of the market.

Although investment schemes existed throughout history, the modern corporation came to life on December 31st, 1600, when Elizabeth Tudor, daughter of Henry Tudor and Ann Boleyn, signed the charter for the East India Trading Company. How you judge the British East India Company depends largely whether you see it through the eyes of the British bartender as he counts the mugs of ale being consumed, or through the eyes of a Dutch sailor as he watches his ship being shredded by English cannon fire. The truth of the matter is that, at this infant stage, the corporation was relatively harmless. But then again, the theologian will tell us that Satan himself was once harmless and then became evil. By September 16th, 1773, rather than being forced to purchase and pay taxes on the monopoly products of the British East India Company, American colonists stormed corporate owned ships in the Boston harbor and tossed the cargo of tea into the water, defying the corporation and the force of the Crown behind it.

Some have condemned the colonists as terrorists for attacking corporate interests and destroying private property, but there’s a problem in this way of thinking. Under natural law property rights only individual people can rightfully own property. The corporation was not an individual person. The corporation was simply an agreement between a group of investors and the State. And since the colonists were not party to the agreement, they were under no obligation to recognize the agreement or the property claims of the corporation. During the 1800’s governments grew closer and closer to corporations until the marriage was consummated and the two became mutually dependent. In the US this happened at or about the time the Supreme Court chose to view corporations as people in the 1886 ‘Santa Clara v. Southern Pacific Railroad’ case. The corporation was a fictitious entity existing only in the mind of people, but suddenly it had the rights of an actual person in the eyes of the so-called law. Further court decisions and acts of various governments have supported and extended this mythology until the bulk of the present generation believes it with unwavering faith.

Once we understand that the corporation is a State authorized entity, solemnly married by contract to government for the purpose of controlling the market, with the legal standing of an actual person, yet without the legal liability of a person, it shouldn’t be difficult to begin to smell something foul about this creature. But having seen that the State first authorized the creation of the corporation, how do we know that the corporation is not the product of the market in spite of the State? Viewing any market where the State is not in control and asking if a company could ever naturally evolve into a self-supported entity, not owned any one person, immune from liability for its actions, can test that theory easy enough. So for example, with the protection of the State, a corporation buried 21,000 tons of toxic waste and then sold it to a school district for $1. The school district then hired other corporations who knowingly constructed schools and low/middle income housing on the toxic dump. This happened at a place called Love Canal in Niagara County New York. After 20 years it was discovered that the residents of Love Canal were suffering horrendous rates of birth defects and all manner of health issues. The US president Jimmy Carter, along with the US congress, stepped in and began pouring vast amounts of tax money on the problem. A couple of the corporations were fined or sued but for the most part those corporations emerged intact, while the US taxpayers absorbed the bulk of the liability. So the question would be, could a group of corporations do this without the protection of the State and come out the other side still doing business?

Keep in mind; the case of Love Canal is not a one-off isolated occurrence. GE legally dumped over 100,000 tons of toxic waste into the Hudson River and the US tax payers are once again left holding the tab. That’s not to mention that just in the year 2000 alone, GE legally pumped 4.4 million ponds of toxic waste into the air. But GE is not even the worst corporate polluter in the US. It ranks below the United States Government, the Honeywell corporation, and the Chevron corporation, who actually give some credence to the silly notion that GE is a “green” company.

So then, would any of these corporations exist if not for the limited liability laws that give them unfair market advantages and protection from the repercussions of their actions?
I can’t imagine anyone even attempting to make that argument.

We see then, that the State created the corporation and the corporation continues to function because the State protects it from the correcting forces of the market. It’s not hard to see that, having this kind of advantage over legitimate businesses, the existence of the corporation distorts the market to the proportion that it engages in the market. But having established these facts, what is this flaw of corporatism that is also the flaw of Statism?

Always remember this one truth. People act. Governments don’t act. Corporations don’t act. The media doesn’t act. The military doesn’t act. Banks can’t act. Even the State itself can’t act. People act. And even though people may act on behalf of any of these entities, ultimately most people act for their own benefit. Their actions are not always successful in benefiting the actor, but people still act primarily for their own benefit.

An example of this truth can be observed in any day-to-day setting of any of the offices of any of the entities listed above. Observe the work habits of any given set of employees of any corporation. How many of these employees will exhibit the kind of work ethic and dedication that’s common in single owner/operated businesses? You’ll always find some outstanding individuals who go above and beyond the minimum expectations, but generally speaking its not because of a devotion to the corporation so much as a desire to succeed for their own benefit mixed with self motivated work ethics unique to that individual. Further, in a privately owned business it’s in the interest of the business owner to recognize and reward the outstanding individual performer. Keeping, developing, and promoting these people is one key to making a small business a success. However in the corporate world, individual performers are often seen as a threat to the office status quo. Coworkers, knowing this person could cause the boss to expect more work from everyone, will single out the over-achiever and look for ways to slow them down or even discredit them. Inept bosses will avoid promoting the over-achiever for fear of having to compete with them on a peer level. The inept bosses will naturally look for someone slightly more inept than themselves for promotion. This is an infectious cycle that drives the mediocre and inept to the leadership of corporations.
Additionally, have you ever considered the thought process of a corporation? A team or a committee decides upon almost every action after washing it though waves and waves of company politics. Before that process finalizes, each new idea must be refined to the point that it’s acceptable to a variety of groups such as a design team, a legal team, a publicity team, and more. And the whole time, if the idea is a flop, there is rarely a single individual that feels the whole sting of failure. Individual employees may own small amounts of stock, but since there is no true ownership in the corporation there is no sense of property. Compare that to how the private businessman thinks. The business is his property and if he has a family, the business is his legacy to pass on. It’s his money and his labor tied up and if he decides to risk his business on a new idea, he will have every incentive to make sure that idea will work.
The result of the lack of true property ownership in a corporation, along with the lack of responsibility for individual actions, is a big stupid corporation dependent on small subcontractors for all the heavy lifting and government bailouts, favoritism, and contracts as the only real source of profit.

Here we see the common strings that tie the Puppet Master to the puppets. The State itself is a big dumb lumbering inefficient relic that was outdated before it was even finished developing. It’s supported by theft and aggression, while lacking any of the aspects of property ownership on the individual level. All of its decisions are made in committee utilizing compromise and the path of least resistance, rather than hard work and dedication to success.

Therefore the State cannot compete with individual accomplishment over the long run. As the State falters and fails it will fall back on its most powerful tool, the corporation. But that institution is founded of the same unstable subsurface as the State and will crumble as the State leans on it. The whole cathedral of cards will fall to the floor as soon as people realize that their best interest is served by not acting to support the State.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Economics, History, Property | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0071 The Flaw of Corporatism is the Flaw of Statism