0062 Buying Silver and Gold

0062 Buying Silver and Gold MP3
(audio player at bottom of page)

Buying Silver and Gold
by Ben Stone

I’m not sure how many times I’ve been asked about precious metals lately but it comes up often enough that I finally decided to try and put my thoughts all in one place.
Please note: I am not affiliated with any sellers of precious metals and make no commissions whatsoever. I am not giving financial advice. I am simply sharing what I have learned. If you know something I don’t know, please feel free to add it to the comments below this article. As always, be polite and helpful and your opinion will be respected.

Why would a person want to own precious metals (PMs)?
I think there are three possible answers to that question, but for me there is only one. PMs are a way to store wealth. But lets take a quick look at the other two reasons.
1) Investing in Collectibles
Whether in the form of jewelry, rare coins, or commemorative objects, collectibles are often made of PMs. However, trading in the collectibles market is risky and requires a lot of specialized knowledge. Also if the economy turns bad, and I mean real bad, no one will care if your gold “clad” commemorative Buck Owens belt buckle once sold for $300. If the economy is bad enough it will only be worth its melt value because no one may care who Buck Owens was or why a belt buckle has his face on it.
So I never invest in collectibles.
2) Playing the PM market for profit
While on the surface this may seem like a good idea considering the current trends in the PM market, this also requires specialized knowledge and is very risky at best. Playing any commodity for profit is one of the more difficult forms of the stocks and bonds market.
So I never try to play the PM market.

What am I talking about when I say I own PMs as a way to store wealth?
Here’s the classic example:
In 1810 a fine hand tailored man’s business suit cost 1 oz of gold.
In 1910 a fine hand tailored man’s business suit cost 1 oz of gold.
In 1910 the dollar was determined by gold, and 1 oz of gold cost $20.
Actions taken in 1913, 1933, 1944, and 1971 removed the connection between gold and the US dollar.
In 2010 a fine hand tailored man’s business suit still cost 1 oz of gold but now cost 1200 US dollars.
So the value of gold stayed pretty much the same, but the value of the dollar is only 1/60 of what it was worth in 1910. That’s a 98% devaluation and most of that devaluation has happened since 1971.

Here’s another classic example of how the dollar has been devalued.
In 1963 a US Quarter coin was made mostly of silver and could buy 1 gallon of gas.
In 2010 a gallon of gas cost about $2.80 but that same day the silver in a 1963 quarter was also worth $2.80.
So from 1963 to 2010 silver and gas stayed about the same, but dollars devalued by 90%.

In these examples I use 2010 because all market prices including gold, silver, suits and gas are changing rapidly and will become more volatile in the years to come, but PMs will always settle to roughly the same real value. Dollars will, however, constantly be worth less and less until they are worth nothing.

So buying precious metals is not a way to make money, it’s a way to preserve the value of the wealth you already have.

Ok, then…
Why has the dollar devalued by 98% since 1910 and by 90% since 1963?
That question can be taken different ways and has several answers.Real Money
The methods used to devalue the dollar were the act of printing new money and the mechanism of credit expansion. In other words, the US Treasury Department can just print new money. But most new money came from the banking system under the Federal Reserve. The Fed makes new money by loaning it into existence.
Keep in mind; the Fed is not a part of the government. It’s a private bank. It is a private bank that can make its own money any time it wants without asking the government. The congress and the president of the US gave the Fed that power in 1913.
Every time The Treasury or the Fed pumps more new money into the system, every dollar is worth a little less because there is more of them.

Now ask yourself this question:
If you ran a bank and you could just make new money whenever you wanted, how much self-control would you have?
Some people believe this devaluing of the dollar and destabilizing of the US economy has been done intentionally by people who want a global currency and ultimately a one world government. But whether by shortsighted greed induced stupidity, or whether by evil men seeking to dominate the world, the end result is the same.
(see my article titled Evil or Stupid)

Where is this all headed?
Whether for good or evil, we are headed for a global currency. But to do that a massive amount of wealth will be transferred out of the hands (and retirement funds) of working Americans, Canadians, Europeans, and Australians.

What can a person do to protect their savings?
Store your wealth in precious metals. And here are some tips on how to do just that.

Rule #1
Avoid numismatics (collectors items)
Some terms you don’t really need to know:
Numismatic – these have collector value due to some factor (composition, rarity, beauty, etc) beyond the melt value of the metal.
Legal tender – can be used to pay debts in some currency (dollars, yen, pounds, euros, etc) and sellers are currently forced to accept them by law.
(American silver eagles are both numismatic and legal tender, but one doesn’t imply the other.)
Common circulated pre-1964 silver dollars, quarters, and dimes, are legal tender, but are not collector’s items.
Liberty Dollar’s Ron Paul coins and coins sold on TV are not legal tender, but are collector’s items.
Generic bullion is not legal tender, and not collector’s items. It’s simply metal. This is what we want.

Now for some things to remember.
Buying Tips
One of the safest ways, in my opinion, to buy PMs is by purchasing rounds and bars (generic bullion) through a trusted dealer.
At the bottom of this article I provide links to online sellers that I have done business with and trust. It’s also good to get to know a couple local coin dealers by dropping by their shop and buying a silver round or two every few weeks. When you go to a coin shop, carry cash. They most likely won’t take plastic of any kind and may or may not accept checks.
Common circulated pre-1964 silver dollars, quarters, and dimes are called “junk silver” and are generally about 90% silver. Some people prefer these coins to rounds and bars, but I find the whole process cumbersome and confusing. They are a good way to buy silver, but require a whole different set of rules for purchase so I don’t recommend junk silver as a person’s entry into PMs.
Likewise, old silverware and silver place settings are popular with the folks who go to estate auctions, but again unless you know what to look for you’re asking for trouble.
Price
The “spot price” is the current market price, usually in ounces. Always know the spot price when you’re about to make a purchase.
The quickest way to find this is to Google the words spot silver or spot gold. You’ll see several sites like Kitco or Monex. The market keeps these sites honest so you can trust their charts.
Remember, the spot price changes constantly, but honest dealers will base their price on it all the time. Once you know the spot price, expect to pay a bit over that amount. After all, the dealer has to make a living and cover their expenses. Most likely they will charge somewhere between $4-8 an ounce commission. If you’re buying locally from a coin shop, you may have to pay sales tax but if you order online you may be able to skip the sales tax but you will have shipping costs.
Large Purchases
You probably won’t be able to make large purchases at a local coin dealer unless you have built a good business relationship with them. Then they will value your business and trust you and can best guide you in the matter. I’ll only say that once you have a good relationship with a local dealer they may be able to give you significant discounts on their commission when making large purchases.
Storing Your PMs Real Money 2
The topic of large purchases quickly brings up the question of what to do with all these rounds and bars. Safely storing PMs is a touchy question and I’ll cover it more fully in a separate article. One thing I don’t recommend is to buy your PMs through the use of “certificates”. This is where banking institutions, dealers, or full-service brokers hold the gold in their vault and issue you a slip of paper and a promise. They do have some advantages and those advantages may be significant, but when you need to get your hands on your investment there can be serious stumbling blocks. Also if the government turns nasty, as the US did in 1933, it can and has confiscated private holdings of PMs and the ones held in certificate form are the easiest for the government to grab.
If, on the other hand, you feel strongly about using certificates I would at least say that you shouldn’t put all your eggs in one basket. And I would recommend using a system where the purchase of the PMs is through a separate organization than the final holder of the PMs. This is the case with AOCS Mint (links below) and The Free Lakota Bank. You can make a safe purchase from AOCS and have it shipped directly to The Free Lakota Bank where they will store it in their vaults. The Free Lakota Bank has a number of advantages to some other institutions, but that’s for another article.
Also moving large amounts of wealth out of retirement funds and into PMs may require the use of stocks in gold producing companies, but I would consider this a last resort rather than taking a giant tax hit on the fund.

Are PM Purchases Tracked or Recorded by The Government
I don’t know about other countries but in the US they are not currently recorded, however that could change.
In 2012, unless the laws change yet again, when you sell anything including PMs over $600 you may have to file tax forms.

Also if you make a purchase of anything greater than $10,000 and you use cash, it will be reported, however it is a “cash reporting transaction.” It is not the PMs that the government wants reported but the cash. Such reporting applies to all business transactions involving more than $10,000 cash. This nonsense is supposed to keep us safe from the drug dealers and the terrorists. But again, this rule is only for cash. It does not apply to personal checks, wire transfers, or money market withdrawals. However, cashier’s checks have layers of goofiness that make them considered both cash and not cash by the idiots that run the insane asylum in Washington DC.

Tarnish
Don’t worry about it. We only care about the weight and the purity, not the looks.
Tarnish is a discoloration that can take place when silver is exposed to some gasses that are naturally found in air. Some air has more of these gasses than other air, so it varies.
If you are worried about it, you can seal the silver in an airtight container and it should help.

Final Thoughts
Another thing about having wealth in the form of PMs is that its a fun way to save while both having the PMs in your hand and not being tempted to cash them in every time you want to splurge on some indulgence.
Also, they make the most impressive gift you can imagine. Rather than giving a friend or relative a mid-value bottle of wine or buying some plastic toy for a child, hand them a Crazy Horse Lakota round and watch their eyes light up.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

LINKS:
I have personally done business on line with these fine folks and couldn’t be happier with their service.
http://www.silverandgoldshop.com/
http://freelakotabank.com/
http://aocsmint.com/
Note: PMs can be purchased at the AOCS Mint web site and directly deposited into your account at The Free Lakota Bank.
http://shiresilver.com/  <~~ Some interesting options for the liberty minded.

Avoid numismatics: Peter Schiff
http://youtu.be/zbDhMoFvdhM

Advice on moving PMs outside of the US by Mark Nestmann
http://lewrockwell.com/nestmann/nestmann31.1.html

Posted in Audio Articles, Economics, History | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0062 Buying Silver and Gold

0061 Lies The State Taught Me Part 1

0061 Lies The State Taught Me Part 1 MP3
(audio article below)

Lies The State Taught Me
part 1
by Ben Stone

FDR Played Us Like A Fiddle

Most American children suffer a prison sentence of 13 years in government schools, but fortunately I was able to graduate a year ahead so I only endured 12 years of indoctrination and institutionalized brainwashing. While in school, I consistently received my highest grades in classes involving history, geography, and civics. As weird as it sounds, in these subjects I would usually read my entire textbook within a few weeks of it being issued to me, so most of the school year I was simply reviewing what I had already covered on my own. Of course the class would almost never make it through the entire book during a school year, which means there were whole chapters the teachers rarely if ever saw. On more than one occasion this practice put me at odds with teachers who made statements that directly contradicted the textbook. When I was very young I would just make a mental note of such instances, but as I grew older I became more bold and began pointing out the teacher’s mistakes. By the time I finished serving the terms of my scholastic incarceration, I learned that there are three versions of history. There is the official one in the textbook, which is cartoonish and at times pure fantasy. There is the one that develops in the mind of people as they attempt to make sense of the textbook version. And there is that which actually happened, but must be discovered outside of the distortions of the first two types.

One lie that was pushed on me by both textbooks and teachers was that free market/laissez-faire policies have been tried and they failed over and over. In the 1800’s the free market caused monopolies and robber barons got rich at the expense of the workers. In the early 1900’s the failure of the free market caused the Great Depression. And I was told that the free market had caused the recession of the 1970’s and the ghettoes and crime of the American cities. It was only through benevolent government intervention that we have survived the ravishes of the greedy capitalists. In this twisted version of history, the State had tried to leave the economy alone, but every time the market would fail and like John Wayne bringing the cavalry in at the last moment, the State had to swoop in and save the day. All facts were pushed aside by the textbooks and my socialist teachers, as the familiar good guys/bad guys theme was given as the driving force of history. And as always, no matter who the good guys were or who the bad guys were, it was the All Mighty State that solved the problem in the end.

Another lie that was placed in such high regard that no one dared question it was the one where naive isolationism in the 1930’s lulled America to become vulnerable and look weak, thus leading to the attack at Pearl Harbor. For me, this one was the first of the big lies that I just couldn’t swallow. As a teen I was fascinated by battle tactics, both land and sea, and the actions of the US prior to December 1941, were clearly the actions of a strong navy baiting a weak navy into a first strike. If you read my article on Impossible Rules of Engagement you’ll see I grasped this tactic at an early age and, like the old saying goes, you can’t trick a trickster.

Let’s pause for a moment and question this sacred myth using only the information I had at hand in the late 1970’s.
If America was isolationist why did Roosevelt sign the Lend Lease Act prior to the attack at Pearl Harbor?
If America was isolationist why did Roosevelt release active duty pilots, technicians, and instructors along with a mini-air force of planes and support equipment to form the Flying Tigers and actively fight the Japanese in Burma prior to the attack at Pearl Harbor?
If America was isolationist why did Roosevelt break off oil and fuel sales to Japan prior to the attack at Pearl Harbor, then refuse to meet with the Japanese delegates on the matter?
If America was isolationist why did Roosevelt establish a separate wide sweeping embargo of Japan prior to the attack at Pearl Harbor?
If America was isolationist why did Roosevelt choose to garrison and fortify both Wake Island and Midway Island along with moving the Pacific Fleet from the relatively safe San Diego Harbor to the exposed, bottlenecked Pearl Harbor? (Each by itself, an act of aggression in the eyes of Japan.)
Wouldn’t any one of these acts by a US president indicate to Japan that the US was a threat and in fact preparing for war and that being the case, wouldn’t Japan fair better in the fight if it hit first and took out the Pacific Fleet?

When I took these questions and others to my high school history teacher back in 1977, he scoffed at me. He contended that thinking like this is backward and I will never understand history if I question the motives of the important leaders that have made America great. He refused to address even one of the central questions but simply asserted that we must trust our elected officials because they know things that the public is unaware of. Besides, looking back at history gives us perfect hindsight. We can’t judge the decisions of people who were dealing with the situation as it happened. If they made mistakes it was just that, mistakes. But I didn’t buy this excuse. Roosevelt’s actions were too close to the feigned innocence I utilized whenever I got in a fight. (Again, see this article.)  And as I look back on it, this smacks of the “stupid or evil” argument I address in this article. However, if it is true that the very president who is consistently hailed as one of America’s greatest leaders, was so stupid as to unintentionally send what was clearly a series of messages to Japan that we were on the verge of engaging them in war, why do we need buffoons like this at the helm of the State? If Roosevelt or any other person could be this stupid, why would we hand them the ability to go to war?

As a final thought, I want to add a story an old sailor told not long after I was out of school. He wasn’t at Pearl when the attack took place because he was on a carrier support ship and all the carriers had been pulled out and were (conveniently) safe. According to him, “vacant sea” orders had been issued just prior to the attack. He claimed that, had routine patrols been continued, ships would have spotted the Japanese fleet in time to bring the big battleships out of Pearl. My first thought was that the battleships would’ve had a fighting chance if they had been at sea. But he corrected me. He said that without the carriers and their support ships the battleships would have been sitting ducks in the open ocean and there would have been a dramatically higher death count. His argument was that by having all the big battleships in the harbor most of the sailors were either safe on shore or could simply swim to shore when their ships went down, whereas if they had been at sea all hands on every battleship would have been lost. He also pointed out to me that almost all the ships “lost” at Pearl were actually only a few feet underwater and were pumped out and back in the war faster than replacements could have been built. Every time we talked about it he would get a little smile and say, “FDR played us like a fiddle.”

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., History | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0061 Lies The State Taught Me Part 1

0060 Practical Bob and his Practical Jar of Answers

0060 Practical Bob and his Practical Jar of Answers MP3
by Ben Stone Ben

Audio version of:
Practical Bob and his Practical Jar of Answers

Wouldn’t it be great if we had a phone app that could whip out the answer to all the standard practical objections people bring up to reject a free society?

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker Fun, Brief Articles and Short Notes, Free Society, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0060 Practical Bob and his Practical Jar of Answers

0059 Fiat Money Is Not Out of Thin Air

0059 Fiat Money Is Not Out of Thin Air MP3
(audio player below article)
updated version
by Ben Stone

I think its important to use our language in a way that best expresses what we intend to say within the restrictions of truth.

Penn Jillette, noted libertarian and juggler, has expressed publicly that he refuses to say “marine mammals” and instead insists on calling dolphins and whales “fish”. Jack Spirko, noted libertarian and rifleman, has said on numerous occasions that he doesn’t make a big deal out of the difference between an ammo clip and an ammo magazine. These simple terminology variances don’t matter in most situations. Both men are correct.
That is, of course, unless you’re a marine biologist speaking about the difference between dolphins and sharks, or if you’re firing an M1 beside your buddy who’s firing an M16 while asking you for ammo. Not likely scenarios, but you can see how these things take on a different level of importance according to the situation.

Such is the case we face when discussing two key phrases, fiat and ex nihilo.
Why would we care about the difference?
Stick with me and maybe I can answer that question.

Fiat roughly means something like “so it is” or perhaps “as it is”. Either way, its clumsy to say in English, thus we say it in Latin. What it actually means is “to accept at face value in faith”. It’s very similar to when we say “amen”. It’s a step in faith saying, “I believe this to be so and will act accordingly”.

Ex nihilo, on the other hand, actually means “out of nothing” or “from nothing” or even “from the air”.

Most of the time a distinction between these two expressions won’t matter. That is, of course, unless you happen to be a theologian debating the creation of the universe, or an economist talking about the value of money. Then the difference becomes critical to your discussion.

Fiat money is money backed by faith. But money has no set value. It only has the value we believe that it has in a particular situation.

Let me give an example; Assume Bill Gates is standing outside a coffee shop with a five-dollar bill in his hand. That five-dollar bill has a dramatically different value to Bill than to the disabled man walking by who is on a fixed income. And it has an even different value to the person inside the coffee shop who will accept it for coffee. To Bill, a cup of coffee is worth more than his five-spot. But the man on a fixed income wouldn’t think of paying five bucks for a cup of coffee. However, the shop attendant will gladly give up a cup of coffee for the money.

So now we have established the difference between the dollar amount printed on the paper and the actual value of the paper to the beholder.

Now lets take the next step.
What if it’s not Bill Gates?
What if it’s Ben Stone and the bill he’s holding is counterfeit? Not just any counterfeit, but a perfect counterfeit. (Notice I said “what if”!) What if Ben has a counterfeiting process and can produce any denomination of bill perfectly and at almost no cost? For the purpose of this demonstration, Ben cannot be caught and he cannot be stopped.
Lets say Ben produces a batch of money and comes into town. He spends $500 at a restaurant then buys two new cars from the local dealership. On the way home from his shopping spree he stops for coffee where he covers everyone’s bill in the coffee shop and leaves a $100 tip with the shop owner.

The effect of this act of counterfeiting is a sudden increase of wealth injected into a very narrow segment of the community, and a sudden devaluing of the money held by the rest of the community. We have already established that the value of money is based on the perception of the beholder. Money is now easier to obtain and therefore less valuable to the restaurant owner but just as hard to get for his other patrons and his cook. Money is now easier to obtain and therefore less valuable to the car dealership owner, but just as hard to get for the other car buyers and the auto mechanics.

Back at the coffee shop the owner may decide that, now that he has this new big shot customer, maybe its time for a price increase. After all what’s another dollar going to mean to a rich guy like Ben? He’ll still buy the coffee.

Ben is not producing money ex nihilo. He is producing money fiat. He is producing money with a perceived value based on what the people of the community believe. And as he does so, the value of the money in the community decreases. Prices go up and wages are slow to respond if they change at all. Those on fixed incomes and those on hourly wages feel the squeeze of higher prices right away as their dollars are worth less and less each time Ben spends money. Again, Ben has not created money out of nothing. The value of the money is placed upon it by perceptions in the community.
Ben stole the value of the money from the low end users of money in the community and redistributed it to Ben and the first users who received it. He did not create any wealth.

Now lets change one more aspect of this scenario.
Lets say Ben’s last name is not Stone.
Lets say Ben’s last name is Bernanke!
When Ben Bernanke produces money it is not out of thin air!
Ben Bernanke produces fiat money through credit expansion. And when he does so he does it at the expense of YOU. It is your wealth and the value of your dollar that is shifted upward to the top end users. The bankers and the Treasury Department get the new money first but the value of the money comes out of your pocket. Prices go up and the poorest people in society pay the most for the credit expansion.
Ben Bernanke doesn’t produce wealth ex nihilo! Ben Bernanke produces money fiat.
Ben steals the value of the money from the low end users while enriching the high end users; he does not create the wealth.
This is what Ron Paul calls an invisible tax and it strikes those on fixed income and hourly wages the hardest, since they are low end users.

So now, this begs the question; how is wealth created?

Well, one example is when you take a seed, put it in the ground, and grow tomatoes. You have invested one seed, mixed your labor with the energy of the sun, elements in the soil and the air, added time, and you produce wealth ex nihilo!
Theologians, please sit down and stop screaming at me! I’m not attacking your religion. I realize you don’t use the phrase that way, but it’s an accurate use of the phrase nonetheless. When you take a resource, invest time and labor, and produce something of more value than the sum of its parts you produce wealth ex nihilo.

Here’s the math:
1 pack of tomato seeds cost $1 and contains 50 seeds; therefore each seed is worth $0.02.
1 seed – $0.02
Sunshine – $0.00
Rain – $0.00
Air – $0.00
Dirt – $0.00
Time – $0.00  (“time is money” but not to a tomato plant)
Your labor – $0.00  (note: I’m not saying your labor is valueless, I’m saying it cost you $0.00)
Tomato price per pound at the store – $1.00
1 plant can produce 8 pounds of tomatoes
0.02 + 0.00 + 0.00 + 0.00 + 0.00 + 0.00 + 0.00 =  $8.00
Therefore by growing one tomato plant you create $7.98 of wealth ex nihilo.

That’s downright inspirational isn’t it?

Ben Stone Ben
revised 2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Economics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

0058 PC17 Riots Being Prepared words Pickens

Episode 17 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

  • Foreign listeners
  • Riots in the UK and preparing for events
  • True anarchists don’t riot and don’t damage property
  • Printing more money and the stupidity of government
  • Foil hatters and conspiracy theories
  • Words have meanings and we should seek the truth
  • Allowing children to learn how to learn
  • Horses and thieves

Original Intro/Exit music by Grenades?!

0058 PC17 Riots Being Prepared words Pickens

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and Sin, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Bad Quaker Theology, Economics, Property, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions, Voluntaryism and the Zero Aggression Principle | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0058 PC17 Riots Being Prepared words Pickens

0057 But Wouldn’t Warlords Take Over?

0057 But Wouldn’t Warlords Take Over? MP3
(audio player below article)

But Wouldn’t Warlords Take Over?
A Mises Daily from Thursday, July 07, 2005 by Robert P. Murphy

Apples and Oranges

When dealing with the warlord objection, we need to keep our comparisons fair. It won’t do to compare society A, which is filled with evil, ignorant savages who live under anarchy, with society B, which is populated by enlightened, law-abiding citizens who live under limited government. The anarchist doesn’t deny that life might be better in society B. What the anarchist does claim is that, for any given population, the imposition of a coercive government will make things worse. The absence of a State is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition to achieve the free society.

To put the matter differently: It is not enough to demonstrate that a state of private-property anarchy could degenerate into ceaseless war, where no single group is strong enough to subjugate all challengers, and hence no one can establish “order.” After all, communities living under a State degenerate into civil war all the time. We should remember that the frequently cited cases of Colombia and now Iraq are not demonstrations of anarchy-turned-into-chaos, but rather examples of government-turned-into-chaos.

For the warlord objection to work, the statist would need to argue that a given community would remain lawful under a government, but that the same community would break down into continuous warfare if all legal and military services were privatized. The popular case of Somalia, therefore, helps neither side.[i] It is true that Rothbardians should be somewhat disturbed that the respect for non-aggression is apparently too rare in Somalia to foster the spontaneous emergence of a totally free market community. But by the same token, the respect for “the law” was also too weak to allow the original Somali government to maintain order.

Robert P Murphy Archive at Mises.org

Continue Reading the Article Here

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., Economics, Free Society, Voluntaryism and Competitive Government, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0057 But Wouldn’t Warlords Take Over?

0056 Evil or Stupid

0056 Evil or Stupid MP3
(audio player below article)

Evil or Stupid
by Ben Stone

There’s an old statement that’s often applied to government: Never attribute to Evil what can be explained by Stupid. I’ve used this phrase perhaps thousands of times, but it has a serious flaw built into it. That flaw is the inference that when Stupid happens Evil is not involved.
I’ll give an example:
There is a stupid man named Tom who lives in a suburb of a large city. Stupid Tom is celebrating his birthday and, in a burst of excitement, he fires his pistol into the air. His shot is not aimed perpendicular to the earth, therefore the bullet maintains a considerable amount of speed as it arcs across the sky and eventually strikes a power transformer knocking out the electricity to a large section of town, causing millions of dollars in lost revenue to businesses that are forced to close until repairs are made.
In this situation, we know Stupid was at fault. And the unpredictable result cannot be Evil because for Evil to exist there must be intent of malice, and Stupid Tom had no intent to harm anyone or anything. He was simply stupid. He should be held accountable for his act, but his stupidity and lack of malice should be considered when he is judged.
On the other hand, if it were the case that Tom would have never thought of firing his pistol. But his brother-in-law, Larry, wanted to harm Tom by getting him arrested for firing a gun in the city limits, so he handed the gun to Tom knowing Tom would shoot, now we have Evil. Not only was it evil of Larry to set Tom up to be arrested, but also the damages done were a direct result of Larry’s evil act! Therefore whether or not Larry intended to cause the specific damages, Evil happened. Its true that Stupid was involved, but the intent was evil so however stupid the act was it was also Evil.
The problem then becomes, how can Larry be held accountable for Tom’s action? Ultimately Tom choose to fire the gun. Larry didn’t even tell Tom to fire it. And it’s impossible to prove what Larry was thinking when he handed Tom the gun. So again, the end result is that Stupid does a stupid thing and Evil results. But Evil cannot be held accountable even though malice was clearly involved.

If we then apply this principle to government we can see another aspect of the State and how it uses the stupidity that is built into government to accomplish evil. I’ll give another example of how this works without a Stupid so that you can see it and better understand the nature of the Beast we face.

A drunk driver tragically kills a woman’s daughter. The woman, whom we will call Candy, fails to understand the basic concepts of justice and how cause and effect work, so she believes government can help solve the problem of drunk driving. With good intent, Candy forms an organization she believes can push the government into passing laws that she believes will save people’s lives. We shall call this organization “Parents Against Drunk Drivers” or PADD. Remember, Candy is neither stupid nor is she evil. She is simply ignorant of the nature of the State.
Some people, both private citizens and those within government, see an opportunity to use the fist of the State to enforce their ideas of morality upon other people, so they join PADD and begin pushing draconian anti-alcohol laws into place. These people are committing an evil act and are using the stupidity of government to accomplish their act.
In this situation, Candy had no malice in founding PADD, and when she saw the result of her actions she withdrew from PADD. But because of her naive act, evil people took over PADD and it, through the fist of the State, is now committing acts of aggression on people who have never harmed anyone.

One evening Tom is relaxing at home with an adult beverage. He gets a phone call and must rush to his office or an important deal will fall through. On his way, Tom finds himself in a Drunk Driver Check Point, organized by PADD, where the police smell his breath and ask him to step out of his car. He takes and passes three field sobriety tests. However the machine that tests his breath indicates he is a tiny amount over the legal limit for blood alcohol. No one accuses Tom of being impaired, however if a 90-pound man who never drinks and has no resistance to alcohol had the same blood alcohol level as Tom, he may show some impairment. So then because of the zero tolerance rules PADD pushed into place, and the one size fits all State justice system, Tom heads to jail for the night. The deal falls through and Tom’s company has to lay-off dozens of workers. Tom is fired and must depend on government aid to live until he can find a new job and get back on his feet. Millions of dollars are lost and innocent people’s lives are altered by the evil acts of PADD and the State. Yet there is no individual who can be held accountable for Evil or the harm it produced.
Supporters of the State may argue that Tom should have called a taxi and not driven, but this position assumes there was something wrong with Tom’s actions rather than accepting that it was the law that was wrong. Remember, Tom harmed no one. All of the harm took place due to the actions of the State and PADD. If the statist argues that Tom could have harmed someone, then the statist is arguing that people should be punished simply for having the potential of action rather than actual action. If people should be punished for possessing the potential of harm, who among us can be found innocent?

In the case of Stupid Tom and Evil Larry, Tom was innocent of any malice and Larry was innocent of any action. Therefore Evil goes unpunished, even though Stupid can carry some of the blame. But the damage that the actions of one or two people can accomplish is very limited. In the worst case, a community is affected and must deal with a local issue. But in the case of Candy and her do-gooder PADD members, once the fist of the State is involved Evil is unleashed upon millions of innocent people on a continual and almost unrelenting wave, wiping out families, businesses, and wealth without regard to consequences. Take this to the next level of the State and apply this principle to foreign policy, and whole cities die, cultures are destroyed, and civilization is altered by Evil.

This is the nature of the State. It blends the good intentions of the ignorant, the acts of the stupid, and the selfish desires of the evil, and it brings to life an inanimate Being that walks the Earth seeking whom He may devour. The problem is not some grand conspiracy by evil men in some hidden grove, nor is it some fellowship of global do-gooders attempting to plan a perfect society at the expense of the workers of the world. It’s not even a plan by select super-rich families desiring global dominance. If these groups exist they are simply tools This Beast uses to accomplish His purposes. The State supersedes individual actors and their intents and is a man-made god who seeks ownership of all that is. Recognizing this single fact allows us to understand that those things that can be explained by Stupid may have more behind them than just a simple evil conspiracy. The stupidity of government is the whip the State uses to drive its herds and punish its foes.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Anarchy and Patriotism

Anarchy, Libertarianism, and Patriotism MP3
By Ben Stone
Originally from May 2011
(MP3 player below article)

Most people will tell you that anarchy and patriotism are mutually exclusive. I would go so far as to say that most anarcho-capitalists, well educated in the nuances of anarchy and libertarian theory believe that a consistent anarchist cannot be a patriot.
I would argue otherwise. I would argue that the meaning of the word “patriotism” has been polluted by “nationalism” and as a result the anarcho-capitalist community has unnecessarily rejected patriotism, which I will argue is not only compatible with natural law and the Zero Aggression Principal, but will be a critical tool for liberty if we are ever to succeed building a free world with free markets and free individuals.
To make my point, consider if the word ‘nationalism’ were represented by the phrase ‘team spirit’ and the word ‘patriotism’ by the phrase ‘friends, family, and community’.
Disclaimer: Like most everything else in life, I see nothing wrong with sports or with having a favorite team when done in moderation. I like American football and “my team” is the Miami Dolphins even though I have never visited Florida and have no desire to ever do so.
So back on target, when you’re a sports fan and you have a team that you’re attached to, your loyalty to that team is not based on the team’s performance or behavior. Fans of the Cincinnati Bengals football team buy-out the season tickets every year. Most games are sold-out in advance and the games and team related discussion dominate local radio year around. Yet the team is almost always a dismal failure on the field of play. The owner shows little understanding of the game and even less interest in the team’s performance. The players are a collection of amazing athletes and criminals who only seem to have one thing in common, an over inflated opinion of their own importance. The disconnect between the team’s performance and the fan bases’ loyalty can be entertaining to observe.
Another example of this odd team devotion can be observed by examining the New England Patriots football team and its fans. The team management is consistently some of the best in the NFL, the individual players are consistently top performers, and yet the team was busted red handed systematically and repeatedly cheating. But don’t bring that up to a “Pats” fan unless you’re prepared to defend yourself physically. Even if that fan is an otherwise moral upstanding person, he will find layers of reasons to remain loyal to the cheating team.
So then I say team spirit is like nationalism.
I remember the team spirit that swept America during and after the First Gulf War. It was like being in Cincinnati if the Bengals had just beat the Detroit Lions 56 to 3. Or perhaps like being in Boston if the Patriots had just beat the Bengals 56 to 3. America was in frenzy and frothing nationalism spewed forth like a putrid fountain at a demonic version of Creaser’s Palace. And why such nationalism? Well, the best trained, best equipped, most technologically advanced military the world has ever seen took on a small third world nation’s outdated under supplied poorly lead military that happened to be using 50 year old technology. Iraq had as much chance against the US as a frail meth addict has against her 300-pound pimp once he decides she’s due a good beat down.
At that moment in time, as the American State reveled in its superiority, there was something odd happening deep in the heart of the American patriot. Seeing photos of slaughtered Iraqi troops wiped out before they even knew the battle was on, and miles of highways littered with the burned corpses of Iraqis trying desperately to retreat, didn’t quite settle well with the American public. State driven media broke into a Hallelujah chorus at the slaughter, but American patriots felt joy and relief that the whole mess was over quickly and the troops could be safely coming home, but still there was just something not right.
Lets pause here and examine this key difference. The American State was elated at the defeat and subsequent humiliation of the Iraqi State. Papa Bush looked strangely out of place as he played the role of tough guy, yet you could tell he loved every moment of it and thought for sure it had sown up the next election for him. However the overwhelming slaughter of the Iraq military followed by a sudden pull back right when complete victory was at hand sent a confused wave through the minds of Americans. What happened? Why was victory so easy, unlike what we had been told to expect, and why did we stop before we finished? We were clearly lied to about the strength of the enemy, and then we were given this bizarre explanation for stopping. The oddity of the moment couldn’t be hidden on the faces of prominent warriors such as Norman Schwarzkopf, as he fiddled and mumbled behind microphones and before cameras, trying to make it all sound legitimate.
I propose the contradicting feelings in America at that time were the effect of patriotism and nationalism clashing.
Think of the American State as a giant nationalistic cat teasing a small mouse. The American State thrilled at each claw mark on the mouse’s nose. But the big cat didn’t need to kill Iraq; she just took pleasure in watching it struggle and tasting its blood.
Patriotism has no place for such cruelty. Patriotism is based on the warrior spirit and the appreciation of the warrior spirit both in ourselves and in an honorable opponent. The warrior is proud to defend his family, his friends, his tribe, and his country but the warrior takes no pleasure in the deed when war is the task. The warrior/patriot has pride in his ability and develops honor through his actions. But he takes no pride and builds no honor by dominating the weak and toying with the beaten. Only cowards, bullies, and thugs take pleasure in hurting the weak. The patriot’s natural reaction is to defend the downtrodden.
Read that again; “Only cowards, bullies, and thugs take pleasure in hurting the weak. The patriot’s natural reaction is to defend the downtrodden.” So we see the difference in the State and the patriot and we begin to see the source of confusion. As we have watched the current manifestation of the State developing in Washington DC more of its true nature is exposed. The State is a cowardly thug. The State will never again purposely take on a strong opponent. It seeks small weak States to lord over. It desires constant low-level war because that kind of war feeds the State and allows it to grow. The patriot/warrior, in contrast, takes pride in defending what is good. Standing strong against aggression honors the patriot. And the patriot is ready to stand against any aggression, no matter how daunting. The patriot is instant to defend his friends, family, clan, tribe, or country against aggression and dishonor. And yet, on a personal level, the patriot is the least likely to be aggressive to others.
So the State is the source of nationalism, while the warrior is the source of patriotism. The State has spent 9,000 years attempting to disguise nationalism as patriotism. And at many times good patriots have been confused by the tricks of the State. Considering patriots have only had a few good teachers, a few scattered writings, and a still small voice that urges them to make things right while the State has brass bands and uniforms, clashing cymbals and banners waving to the rhythm of national song.

Some items the State has stolen and perverted:
The National Flag is a perversion of the warrior’s banner, a symbol of the nobility of his heritage and his independence.
The National Song is the socialist version of the many spontaneous songs that would breakout as warriors arose to defend their honor, singing songs of bravery and victory.
The Salute as a military gesture was once a source of common respect and trust among warriors, but twisted by the State it has become a tool for lesser men to show authority over true warriors.

These are only a few examples and I would take great joy in examining each one in a separate article, but for now let it suffice to say that the heart of the patriot is naturally stirred as he sees the National Flag unfurled or as he hears the National Song because these things were once the property of the warrior. However they have been largely usurped by the State with the express intention of confusing the patriot. And we must see this, the State stole these things because nationalism is false and empty and it is only by theft and deception that the State can convince patriots to support its ongoing aggressions. It is only through deception and theft that the State can convince true warriors to fight its wars. Nationalism is void of bravery because nationalism sits behind a desk and sends others to fight. Nationalism is quick to wave a flag and just as quick to drop it on the ground as soon as the parade passes. Nationalism sees to it that the National Anthem is trumpeted at every meaningless sports gathering by dimwitted pop stars who don’t even know the words and couldn’t hit the tune if it were duct-taped to a board and they were given a hammer. Nationalism is the hollow dead emotion the State wants patriotism to become. Nationalism is the false pride in one’s self at the accomplishments of others, while patriotism is pride in individual accomplishment. For example, I have no right to pound my chest in pride because the US was the first nation to reach the moon. However when I see the grainy images of Neil Armstrong stepping out onto the surface of the moon my heart swells with pride in that brave man and the individuals that worked and dedicated themselves to making that moment happen. A different example of the contrast between nationalism and patriotism comes in the way we look at war. If I say something like, “We kicked Japan’s butt back in WWII” I am expressing false pride in something in which I was not involved. But if I say, “Americans are resilient, and even when we get knocked down, we get back up. Remember how brave Americans stood up to and defeated Imperial Japan.” Then I’m expressing patriotism and legitimate pride in the accomplishments of others while saying I too will act this way when the chips are down.
The point I am hammering on and hope I haven’t butchered, is that even though there is no place for nationalism in a free society, patriotism and the warrior spirit are a natural and needed aspect of freedom. The trick is in separating the two, as Paul the apostle once said, “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.”
At some point in time, it will become critical for the anarchists and the libertarians to understand and embrace patriotism and loudly proclaim the falsity of nationalism. I hope the writing of this article will help this along to some extent before necessity demands it.

Ben Stone Ben
2011

Posted in Audio Articles, Bad Quaker and War., Free Society, History | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Anarchy and Patriotism

0055 Interview 003 with Jeffrey Tucker

0055 Interview 003 with Jeffrey Tucker
Bad Quaker Dot Com interview with Jeffrey Tucker, editorial vice president of the Ludwig von Mises Institute and author of Its A Jetson’s World and Bourbon For Breakfast.

Featured in this episode:

  • The Ludwig von Mises Institute and the information leap
  • How the internet is saving us from an even worse economy
  • Jeffrey’s uplifting writing style
  • The beauty and art of Liturgical music and chant
  • Private property, market forces, entrepreneurship, and peaceful social cooperation
  • The future and the present Jetson’s world

0055 Interview 003 with Jeffrey Tucker MP3 Jeffrey Tucker

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker Fun, Bad Quaker Theology, Economics, Free Society, History, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0055 Interview 003 with Jeffrey Tucker

0054 Episode 16 Monopolies Justice and Birth Control

Episode 16 Bad Quaker Podcast
with Ben and Ki

Featured in this episode:

  • Lightning strike and information outages
  • State supported monopoles and the managed market
  • Woodpecker headed justice and how the State is punishing a child for saving a bird
  • $500 fine and 1 year in jail for letting your child save a baby bird
  • Link to article To Establish Justice
  • Ann of Green Gables and free societies
  • Project Gunrunner: U.S. ATF Secretly Supplying Guns to Mexico Drug Cartels
  • Ki talks about free government birth control and feminism

Original Intro/Exit music by Grenades?!

0054 Episode 16 Monopolies Justice and Birth Control

Posted in All Podcasts, Bad Quaker and Taxes, Economics, Voluntaryism and Law, Voluntaryism and Social Interactions | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on 0054 Episode 16 Monopolies Justice and Birth Control